As a popular ‘dream kitchen’ wishlist item, the island has evolved from a block design to a multi-functional hub. Equipped with cooking and cooling appliances, extra sinks and taps, and stylish seating spots, I wonder – can it replace the dining table?

Gas versus induction has been a hot debate for some time now, but here is another discussion that has sparked my interest recently – kitchen island versus dining table. I’ve asked the experts for their take on this topic, and the answers are divided…

Yes, it can!

From breakfast bars for enjoying your morning coffee and chef tables fit for hosting to split levels for added functionality, the island is no longer a purely aesthetic feature; it has become the hotspot for spending family time, entertaining and even dining. “A kitchen island can certainly be used to replace a dining table, and this can be particularly effective in spaces that aren’t large enough for both,” says James Bodsworth, creative director at Daval Furniture.

“We’re also increasingly seeing the dining table being replaced with a sofa or sofa and armchair set-up in a kitchen for that real open-plan living aesthetic, and in this case, the kitchen island becomes an important multi-purpose feature used for everything from food prep to working from home to eating as a family,” he explains.

So, if you are designing your new space and you’d love to have an island but there isn’t enough space for a separate dining table, perhaps there are ways you can have the best of both worlds…

How can an island replace a dining table?

There are a couple of key considerations to ensure your design is suitable for food preparation or cooking as well as dining. Molly Chandler, designer at Willis & Stone, advises to first think about the number of people who regularly use the space. “Ideally, there should be around 24–30 inches (60-75 cm) of space per person to comfortably serve meals. If you have a large family, this will mean a large island unit which may not be possible depending on your room size. 

“The island shouldn’t look out of proportion in the room and fit comfortably within the kitchen without overcrowding the space. You will need to allow at least 36–48 inches (90-120 cm) of clearance around the island for easy movement and appliance access,” she says.

And, as with any dining set-up, you need to ensure you’ve got plenty of comfortable seats, which are at a suitable height relative to the island. “A standard kitchen island height is 36 inches (90cm, counter height) or 42 inches (106, bar height) and the overhang for seating should be around 12–18 inches (30-45cm) to allow for sufficient legroom,” recommends Molly.

“If there isn’t space, then the bar-style of one or two sides of seats will, for many people, work perfectly for evening meals with children or a couple because it is about cooking, eating and entertaining in the same space,” suggests Nathan Kingsbury, creative director at Nathan Kingsbury Design.

Complete your design with a good lighting scheme, which can help you set the perfect mood for dining. “Dimmer controls are great for creating a cosy, intimate dining set-up when you do sit down for meals,” says Nathan.

An island should be complementary

However, while some experts say that through careful planning, a kitchen island can replace the dining table, others disagree. “A kitchen island is a fantastic space to cook and entertain at the same time; it’s the perfect spot for guests to sit, chat, and enjoy a drink while you prep. It also doubles as a great serving station, at the ideal height for standing and serving food,” says Melissa Hutley, co-founder and interior designer at Hutley & Humm.

“However, I would never recommend using it as a replacement for a dining table. While an island is convenient for a quick bite or drink, it’s not designed for relaxed, atmospheric dinners or long, leisurely conversations with friends. We believe it should complement, not replace, a dining table,” she explains.

Interior designer Laura Stephens agrees: “Islands are useful for many things but for me, they cannot replace a dining table. Primarily people tend to sit in a row or maybe ‘round a corner’, which does not lend itself to convivial conversation. Islands tend to be at least 90cm high, so bar stools are needed, and without big, upholstered seat-type stools they are rarely comfortable for more than perching at for a quick supper or a glass of wine!”

Why not have the best of both worlds?

Luckily, these days, there are plenty of creative ways of incorporating a dining table within your actual island design – no need to give up one for the other. Popular solutions include banquette seating and dining table combos or split levels perfect for cooking together, and then enjoying meals in the same space.

“For more comfort, some islands are designed with two different heights – a lower area for dining and a higher area for food preparation. This also helps to create a natural divide between cooking and eating spaces,” says Molly.

Ashley Collins, senior designer at Halcyon Wigmore Street, agrees and says: “An island with a drop-seating area connected for dining is a great solution if your space doesn’t allow for a dining table and an island. So instead of having to choose which one to sacrifice, this solution allows our clients to have all the aesthetics of an island, with the functionality of a dining space integrated.”

So, before you make a decision, carefully analysing your family dynamics, daily needs, and lifestyle is crucial. “If your family enjoys casual dining or quick meals, an island will work well however, if you have a large family and enjoy hosting more formal dining or larger gatherings, you may still want a separate dining table,” adds Molly.

Enjoyed this post? Click here for more kitchen island ideas with seating

About Post Author